Showing posts with label Reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

Book Review: "The Witness of Preaching" (3rd edition) by Thomas G. Long

Thomas G. Long, The Witness of Preaching, 3rd ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2016).  280 pp.  $35.00.

[Caution...that 4/5 is a bit misleading.]

To be honest, this is a book in which I agree with about 90% of the content. I have an infinite amount of respect for Tom Long, and reference him repeatedly in my multiple preaching classes. His passion for preaching and depth of wisdom has advanced the study and practice of homiletics in many ways.

That being said, and for as high of a rating that I gave this third edition (which really is the best edition, given the updating on issues like technology, plagiarism and the preacher's spiritual life), I ultimately do not accept Long's concept of "witness" as the paradigm for understanding the preacher's task.

I think to ignore the other paradigms that he discusses (and then dismisses) -- herald, storyteller and pastor -- seriously limits our ability to preach the gospel in a post-Christian society. Yes, this sounds counter-intuitive, given the theological nature of "witness." 

The issue, I have long thought, is two-fold: 

  1. Preaching must be about more than what we have simply "seen and heard" but also point towards transformation, a concept that Long finds deeply problematic to his Reformed approach to the Christian faith.
  2. Preaching must, therefore, employ various models and methods in order to effectively preach the gospel in a distracted culture. Heralds (prophets, John the Baptizer), storytellers (Qoheleth, the Gospel writers, Jesus) and pastors (Paul, Peter, Jude) have long advanced the gospel through a variety of communicative forms. Why, then, should contemporary preachers do any less?
If only witness was promoted as a "best practice" among a variety of best practices, much like Robert Stephen Reid's "four voices." Then, to me, this would be the homiletics textbook that we both need and deserve.

Note: This review was not solicited.  It was originally posted on my Goodreads page.

Monday, December 25, 2017

Books I Read in 2017

I have used Goodreads' feature for the last couple of years to share what I have read in a year.  However, I cannot distinguish specifically what types of books that I have read.  So, here is what I have read categorically in 2017.  I hope you find some inspiration here!

- Fiction

  • **Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale
  • *Philip Dick, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
  • Philip Dick, The Man in the High Castle
  • T.S. Eliot, The Wasteland and Other Writings
  • James Hannah, The A to Z of You and Me
  • *Madeline L'Engle, A Wrinkle in Time
  • John LeCarre, Our Kind of Traitor
  • Dennis Lehane, Live by Night
  • Cormac McCarthy, Child of God
  • *Cormac McCarthy, No Country for Old Men
  • Arthur Miller, Broken Glass
  • **George Orwell, 1984
  • Philip Roth, The Plot Against America
  • William Shakespeare, Macbeth
  • *William Shakespeare, Much Ado About Nothing
  • William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet
  • Jeff Vandermeer, Annihilation
- Biblical Studies

  • *David Bartlett, Romans
  • *Dave Bland, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Solomon
  • *Charles Cousar, Reading Galatians, Philippians and 1 Thessalonians
  • **Peter Enns, The Bible Told Me So
  • Beverly Gaventa, First and Second Thessalonians
  • Robert Jewett, The Thessalonian Correspondence 
  • Derek Kidner, The Message of Ecclesiastes
  • Thomas Mann, Deuteronomy
  • Bonnie Thurston, Reading Ephesians, Colossians and 2 Thessalonians
  • N.T. Wright, Galatians and Thessalonians
  • N.T. Wright, Romans, Part One: Romans 1-8
  • N.T. Wright, Romans, Part Two: Romans 9-16
- Education

  • *Lorrie Blair, Writing a Graduate Thesis or Dissertation
  • Leisyte and Wilkesmann, Organizing Academic Work in Higher Education
  • *Stabile and Ershler, Constructivism Revisited in the Age of Social Media
  • *Ernest Stringer, Action Research
  • Marshall Welch, Engaging Higher Education
- Ministry


  • *Herring and Elton, Leading Congregations and Nonprofits in a Connected World
  • Ron Susek, Firestorm
  • **Thomas Tumblin, AdMinistry
- Preaching/Communication


  • *Jeffrey Arthurs, Preaching with Variety
  • Decker and York, Speaking with Bold Assurance
  • Gonzalez and Jimenez, Pulpito
  • *Hogan and Reid, Connecting with the Congregation
  • Eunjoo Mary Kim, Preaching the Presence of God
  • *Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media
  • Lane Sebring, Preaching Killer Sermons
  • Frank A. Thomas, They Like To Never Quit Praisin' God
- Psychology/Leadership

  • *Brene Brown, Daring Greatly
  • *Angela Duckworth, Grit
  • **Viktor Frankl, Man's Search for Meaning
  • *Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed
  • Sebastian Junger, Tribe
- Theology (Systematic, Spiritual)

  • *Bland and Webb, Creation, Character, and Wisdom
  • *Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Creation and Fall/Temptation
  • **David Congdon, The God Who Saves
  • *Zach Hoag, The Light is Winning
  • Kyle Idleman, Grace is Greater
  • *Kelly Kapic, Embodied Hope
  • *C.S. Lewis, A Grief Observed
  • *Kevin C. Neese, The Gospel According to Star Trek
  • John Walton, The Lost World of Adam and Eve
  • Lisa Whittle, 5-Word Prayers
  • *Brian Zahnd, Sinners in the Hands of a Loving God
- Miscellaneous

  • Harriot Castor, Starting Chess
  • *Richard Rothstein, The Color of Law
The books marked with an (*) are the ones that I enjoyed a little more, and the ones marked with an (**) were my favorites from 2017.  What did you read?  Did you read any that I did?  What recommendations do you have?  Leave your comments below or connect with me on Twitter.  And happy reading in 2018!

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

Review: "Make a Break for It" by Bill Purvis

Bill Purvis.  Make a Break for It: Unleashing the Power of Personal and Spiritual Growth.  Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2016.  216pp.  $21.99.

According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, one defines “direction” as “the path along which something moves, lies, or points” or “an order or instruction to be followed.”  Both are fitting definitions when applied to the realm of spiritual development.  On one hand, we, from the moment we are born to the moment we expire, are moving along a direction.  We have a starting point (mine was in December 1978, in Huntington, West Virginia), and we have will have a stopping date (still working on that one).  The time in between our starting point and our stopping point is the direction of our life, or “trajectory,” as one of my college Bible professors referred to.  We begin, we move along for a while, then we end.  Direction.
            On the other hand, we, from the moment we are born to the moment we expire, are following directions.  Some of those directions are instinctual (crying when we are spanked at birth), some of those directions are intentional (the directions that I give my students in order to complete a paper or project), and some of those directions are accidental (pointing blindly at a wrench when fixing an appliance and your son actually brings you the correct item).  Regardless of the purpose of the direction, we will find ourselves following directions throughout the course of our direction of life.  We begin, we move along for a while, then we end.  Direction.
            Yet, should life not be more than simply follow directions as we follow along a direction?  This is the idea that is at the heart of Bill Purvis’ new book Make a Break for It.  As he writes in the introduction, “Do you ever feel as if your whole life is stuck in a traffic jam, on idle as you wait. . .and wait. . .and then wait some more for a lane to open up so you can get on the fast track to where you want to be?  Or maybe you feel more like you’re in a roundabout.  You keep going around in circles, driving past one exit after another because you don’t have any idea where you’re supposed to go next” (p. 11).  As Purvis argues throughout his book, life should be more than beginning, moving along for a while, and then ending.
            Purvis’ story begins somewhat like you would imagine a published testimony to start—a young man trapped in a broken life fueled by vices.  Yet Purvis’ story is not your usual testimony material.  His testimony includes being stabbed in the heart by a pimp who tried to murder him and his friend.  Just let that line sink in for a moment.  Escaping that moment led Purvis to a true “come to Jesus moment”—a hospital bed confessional that leads to a young man committing his life to not only follow Christ but seek to lead others to Christ. 
However, before you part company with Purvis 20 pages in because you—like me—have a boring testimony, I encourage you to stick with him.  This is not Augusten Burroughs’ This Is How, a brash, abrasive therapy session where you almost feel guilty for not being more broken.  [BTW, I like Burroughs’ book.]  Nor does this delve into sappy sentimental religiosity.  The chapters that follow Purvis’ testimony are carefully-crafted conversations about life, redemption and the self-sacrificial love of God.  It is a book about living well, about moving past excuses and criticisms, about choosing mentors well, and about living the adventure of life. 

This book is about direction—about beginning, about moving along for a while, and about ending.  Yet, Purvis argues, all of this direction should be taken with purpose—purpose which is found in God because it is only God who can give us direction for our direction in life.  So, in Purvis’ words, make a break for it—break away from your direction-less life and allow this redeemed journeyman guide you to a better direction for your life.

Thursday, March 5, 2015

Review: "More: From Messes to Miracles" by Tammie Head

There is an ancient practice in Celtic Christianity called the “soul friend.”  Essentially, it was the earliest systematized form of the contemporary practice of mentoring where one Christian seeks guidance, instruction or discipline from another Christian.  In many ways, Tammie Head’s book More functions like a “soul friend.”  Head, a Christian woman who has overcome a great deal of adversity in her life, including a teenage shotgun marriage and escaping the sex trade industry, does not offer a treatise on Christian theology nor does she offer an organized plan for spiritual growth.  What she does offer is a conversation, a conversation about faith.  She is honest about her faults and struggles, especially those about her marriage and pride in ministry.  She does offer some thoughts and reflections on some spiritual disciplines that have been helpful to her, like intercessory prayer and reading scripture.  However the bulk of the content comes in the form of stories collected over a lifetime of spiritual peaks and valleys.  The ultimate goal of her book is simple: God can redeem any messy person and turn him or her into a glorious spiritual miracle.  The chapters do not necessarily follow any particular progression but function more like informal conversations around a dinner table or in a coffee shop.  There is a lot of good stuff here, a buffet of stories and insights that can benefit readers in only one chapter doses or in reading the entire book at once.

As basic and conversational as this book is, there are a few faults that I had with it.  For the most part, these are fairly small details, however I think they are worth noting.  First, there are a few places where the author refers to her readers as “daughters of God.”  Now, I get it—very few men are going to read this book; it is written more for women.  However, as a male reader and as one who gets aggravated when male writers assume only men will read their books, I think Head does herself a disservice by assuming that only women will read her book.  As I mentioned above, there is a lot of good stuff here that can benefit any reader, regardless of gender.  Second, the author gets a little repetitious in some of her comments and stories.  This was not so much of a returning to stories in order to continue telling them as much as it was repeating stories as if that particular story had not been told previously.  Third—and this one is a little theological—the author mixes or equates the roles of God and Jesus in a way that made me scratch my head a time or two.  From an evangelical perspective, I can understand the blurring of Trinitarian personalities because we teach them as one in the same.  However, from an academic perspective, this reflects a lacking in biblical and theological competency that is problematic, especially for skeptical, unchurched readers.

Overall, I think this is a good book that will a helpful read for those who are looking for some encouragement on how God can turn our messes into miracles.

Monday, December 29, 2014

Books I Read in 2014

Each year, I offer the list of books that I read in that calendar year.  In keeping with this tradition, here is the list of books that I read in 2014.  For reviews of most of these, you can check out my Goodreads page or past posts on this blog.  Hope these may inspire your reading habits in 2015!

Books I Reviewed in 2014

  • Henry Cloud, Never Go Back: 10 Things You'll Never Do Again
  • Sharmila Ferris and Hilary Wilder, The Plugged-In Professor: Tips and Techniques for Teaching with Social Media
  • Randy Harris, Life Work: Confessions of an Everyday Disciple
  • Marybeth Hicks, Teachable Moments: Using Everyday Encounters with Media and Culture to Instill Conscience, Character, and Faith
  • Bob Hostetler, Life Stinks...And Then You Die: Living Well in a Sick World
  • Mike Neary, Howard Stevenson and Les Bell, Towards Teaching in Public: Reshaping the Modern University
  • John Ortberg, Soul Keeping: Caring for the Most Important Part of You
  • Robert Pazmino, A Boy Grows Up in Brooklyn: An Educational and Spiritual Memoir
  • Glenn Pemberton, After Lament: Psalms for Learning to Trust Again
  • Carl Prude, Anchored in Light: Understanding and Overcoming the Five Deadliest Threats to Your Faith
Books I Read for Classes I Teach

  • George Bullard, Every Congregation Needs a Little Conflict
  • Dave Hansen, The Art of Pastoring: Ministry Without All the Answers (revised edition)
  • Timothy Keller, Walking with God through Pain and Suffering
  • Thomas G. Long, What Shall We Say? Evil, Suffering, and the Crisis of Faith
  • Daniel Overdorf, One Year to Better Preaching
  • Andy Stanley and Bill Willits, Creating Community: 5 Keys to Building a Small Group Culture
Books I Read for My Last Doctoral Class

  • Dave Bland and David Fleer, Performing the Psalms
  • David Brooks, The Social Animal: The Hidden Sources of Love, Character, and Achievement
  • Roger Fisher and Daniel Shapiro, Beyond Reason: Using Emotions as You Negotiate
  • Glenn Pemberton, Hurting with God: Learning to Lament with the Psalms
  • Fleming Rutledge, And God Spoke to Abraham: Preaching from the Old Testament
Books I Read to Strengthen My Ministry

  • Mark DeVine and Darrin Patrick, Replant: How a Dying Church Can Grow Again
  • David Helm, Expositional Preaching: How We Speak God's Word Today
  • Timothy Keller, Every Good Endeavor: Connecting Your Work to God's Work
  • Erwin McManus, The Artisan Soul: Crafting Your Life into a Work of Art
  • Thom S. Rainer, Autopsy of a Deceased Church: 12 Ways to Keep Yours Alive
  • Philip Yancey, Prayer: Does It Make Any Difference?
Books I Read Because I Like a Good Story

  • Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
  • Gillian Flynn, Gone Girl
  • Gayle Forman, If I Stay
  • John Green, An Abundance of Katherines
  • John Green, Paper Towns
  • Lois Lowry, The Giver
  • Yann Martel, The Life of Pi
  • Cormac McCarthy, The Orchard Keeper
  • Cormac McCarthy, The Road
  • Arthur Miller, Death of a Salesman
  • Frank Miller, The Dark Knight Returns
  • George Orwell, Animal Farm
  • Ayn Rand, We the Living
  • Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians 1: The Lightning Thief
  • Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians 2: The Sea of Monsters
  • Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians 3: The Titan's Curse
  • Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians 4: Battle of the Labyrinth
  • Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians 5: The Last Olympian
  • Thornton Wilder, Our Town
  • Sun Zhu, The Art of War

Thursday, October 16, 2014

Teaching Notes: What I've Learned (So Far) from Teaching a Course on the Pentateuch

A couple notes of context: I teach at a private, faith-based university.  It is a university that was once a "Bible college," a school that specifically trained ministers.  That changed a few years ago when my university adopted more of a liberal arts approach, offering degree programs in various fields while offering said instruction from the perspective of a Christian vocational worldview. 

Thus, along with the expansion of our athletic programs, our student body began to change.  Previous student bodies were predominantly Christian.  Over the last several semesters, at least since I have been employed by the university, the demographics have changed.  As the programs that the students study have diversified, the level at which our students engage in spirituality has diversified.  Mine is still very much a Christian, faith-based university, although how we engage in that mission is changing

Additionally, I am primarily a ministry professor, specializing in homiletics, pastoral care and leadership.  My first couple of forays in university teaching were by teaching Bible courses.  In fact, my first semester at my current university was spent teaching courses on John's gospel and the Pastoral Letters.  That was in 2009.  The next time I taught a Bible class was in the summer of 2013 when I taught a course on Luke's gospel.  It was online. . .as were the next couple of Bible courses that I taught.

Until this semester.  This semester, I am teaching a traditional, in-seat course on the Pentateuch (the first five books of the Old Testament [or Hebrew Bible]) to 40 students from across our various academic programs.  As a preacher, I have spent several years teaching the Bible to various groups, both Christian and non-Christian.  I have spent years trying to discern contemporary meaning from ancient texts.

Teaching a course on the Pentateuch has proved to be no different.  There are several students in my class who come from strong Christian homes.  They have learned the stories contained with the Pentateuch over and over again in Sunday school and through sermons.  Some of them are even courageous enough to engage in classroom discussion about the morality, history, mythology and literary contexts of these wonderful and winsome stories of faith.  At one time the majority of students on our campus, their percentage is moving closer and closer to the center with each consecutive semester.

Other students come from moderately to less-moderately religious homes.  They have wandered in and out of church for most of their lives.  They wonder why people like me get so giddy when talking about Adam and Eve or Abraham negotiating with God or Moses striking rocks, yet they wonder if they are not missing something by not knowing the stories better than they do.  They have heard of Noah and Joseph.  They may have seen a Bible-based film on documentary on television.  They are at our school for a variety of reasons, too many to go into hear because they reasons are as diverse as the students themselves.  However, when class begins, they perk up in attention because mysterious is being discussed.  As in most religiously-affiliated schools across the country, these students are quickly becoming (or may already be) the majority.

A smaller yet growing number of students in my class are hearing these stories for the first time.  They come because of the chance of leaving a difficult life behind.  Maybe their expectations are too high; maybe they just want to do something different.  Whatever their reason, they are sitting in a Bible class in eastern Kentucky and listening to a young professor ramble on about ancient stories of heroism and tragedy.  Maybe they become interested like some of the students at my last university appointment who decided to give this religious stuff a chance.  Maybe they don't.  The point is that they are there and they must be taught something.

So, with all of this in mind, here are a few tips that I have picked up this semester from teaching a course on the Pentateuch.  Maybe you'll find them useful; maybe you have some of your own to offer.  I do not offer these as professional standards for teaching this subject.  Despite my RateMyProfessor.com rating (it's only 1 score), I am not asserting myself as the guru on teaching Biblical studies.  [That honor should go to Harding University's Kevin Youngblood or Hendrix College's Robert Williamson.]  Please feel free to leave comments below, tweet me ideas of email me for a lengthier
  1. Make them read from their Bibles.  This one is hard to accomplish in class.  I know it seems strange to say this, yet I have found it to be true.  It's like asking for volunteers at church.  You can hear the crickets already.  So, how do I accomplish this?  I assign a portion for them to read each week.  "Sure, but are they are actually reading?" you may ask.
  2. Require a reading journal.  "Yes, they are," I would respond.  I know because I require the students in my Bible classes to keep a reading journal, regardless of subject.  It is a simple guided journal, asking questions about the content of the passage assigned, what the learned from the assigned commentary reading and how it relates to the passage assigned, and what spiritual truths or devotional practices they may have picked up from the passage assigned.  "So, you just teach the Bible, then?" is probably your next question.
  3. Don't get lost in mythology or history.  "Well, mostly.  It is a Bible class, after all," would be my response.  There is certainly a place for walking through the Epic of Gilgamesh when discussing the creation and flood stories, just as the story of Exodus loses some of its cultural relevance when we avoid looking at the connections between Moses and Sargon the Great.  However, in my context, I think I do my students a disservice if I focus most of our attention on ancient mythology and cultural history rather than looking at the Old Testament text.  Connections must and should be made to other ANE cultures, but not at the sacrifice of God's story.  "So, you just preach then, don't you?"
  4. De-sanitize the Sunday school lessons.  "Yes and no," I would respond.  Yes, I have a tendency for "preaching" in class.  I am, by nature, a preacher.  However I am also a scholar.  As a preacher, I tell stories, yet I am not glossing over them as we may do in church.  Notice how Abraham and Isaac's relationship changes after the sacrifice.  Notice that Jacob does not punish his sons after they slaughter an entire family.  How do we rationalize the plague of the death of the firstborn?  These are the questions that fuel the conversations and content of my course.  "Huh," you might say.
  5. Liberally use technology.  My last tip is an "easter egg" in that it is simply something that I would recommend for any teacher in today's techno-friendly culture.  There is a lot of really good stuff that is easy to find on the Internet that will benefit any Pentateuch teacher.  Whether it is a breakdown on the Documentary Hypothesis (I NEVER thought I would ever teach this), a map of the various Exodus routes, a to-scale rendering of the tabernacle or stacks of high-quality classic Christian art, the Internet really can be your friend.  Also, see how you LMS can enhance your teaching outside of the traditional lecture material format.  My students broke up into groups and are writing Wiki pages on each book of the Pentateuch rather than writing research papers.  And they, mostly, seem to be enjoying the challenge.
I am looking forward to the rest of the semester.  Putting this course together week-in and week-out has been one of the more challenging courses that I have ever taught.  Yet engaging students in hearty discussions and learning their stories of faith has been worth it.

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

Review: Life Stinks...And Then You Die (ACU Press Book Club)



Bob Hostetler.  Life Stinks…And Then You Die: Living Well in a Sick World.  Abilene, TX: Leafwood Publishers, 2013.  240 pp.  $14.99.

There are two areas of study in theology that I absolutely love—the Wisdom Literature and spiritual formation.  To be honest, their studies often dovetail nicely with one another.  This is what Bob Hostetler offers in his newest volume Life Stinks…And Then You Die—a study of Ecclesiastes that instructs the reader on how to live faithfully in a “sick” world.  Thus, when I saw this volume on the review list for ACU Press and Leafwood Publishers’ Book Club, I knew that I needed to read it (even if I did not get the chance to review it for the club).

There were a couple of times, as I was reading it, that people would look at the cover and ask me something like they hoped that I did not feel that way or did I actually like the book because the title bothered them so much.  To both questions, I affirmed that I did think life stinks and that I was enjoying the book. 

Now, let me address what I mean by this: Hostetler’s argument is that life , at least in the mind of the writer of Ecclesiastes (whom Hostetler believes to be Solomon), does, in fact, stink.  We do live in a broken, messed-up, polluted, hazardous, imbalanced world.  We can point to all kinds of groups and pass the blame unilaterally to them for why our world is the way that it is.  Yet, as Hostetler demonstrates, each and every human who has ever lived is to blame for why our world “stinks.”  Our choices, often influenced by folly and greed, led to disease, disaster, destruction and death.  The result of millions of bad choices over thousands of years leads the writer of Ecclesiastes (and Hostetler as interpreter) to one unarguable conclusion—life does stink.  Living in this world is difficult and dangerous.

However, just as the writer of Ecclesiastes discovered, this does not have to dictate how each one of us lives in this “sick world.”  Yes, we will experience disaster and heartache.  Just this morning, I received a text from a student who asked me to pray for a member of his family that was experiencing a tragic loss.  Last week I visited with a former minister who has suffered great illness and loss, both personally and professionally, yet he lives with contentment in his heart because his trust is not found in this world but in God.  Life does stink; yet, with God’s grace, we can endure. 

The cover of Hostetler’s book is a great image for the message of the book.  On the cover is a profile of a young woman with a clothespin clamping her nose closed.  Life stinks; yet we do not have to be influenced by the smell.  If we remember our Creator and seek after the Creator’s ways, then we can live well in this sick world. 

Overall, I enjoyed Hostetler’s book.  I thought his study approach was thoughtful and well-developed.  I thought his prayers at the end of each chapter were poignant and the study guide at the end of the book will prove useful to classes or study groups.  This is not meant to be a scholarly study of Ecclesiastes, so I will reserve any technical comments.  In general, this is a great read for anyone wondering what Ecclesiastes has to say to us as we continue to live in this “sick world.”

Rob O’Lynn, ABD
Assistant Professor of Preaching and Ministry
Kentucky Christian University

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from ACU Press/Leafwood Publishers as part of their ACU Press Bookclub Program.  I was not required to write a positive review.  The opinions I have expressed are my own.  I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Monday, April 14, 2014

Review: Soul Keeping


John Ortberg.  Soul Keeping: Caring for the Most Important Part of You.  Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2014.  207 pp.  $22.99.


Peter the Apostle once wrote of his fellow apostle Paul that Paul wrote to Christians out of “the wisdom given him” although some of his writings are “hard to understand” (2 Peter 3:15-16).  I feel this way about the writings of Dallas Willard.  Willard was such a wise Christian, a man full of immense learning and inscrutable humility.  However, I have struggled to finish any of his books—let alone understand what he is writing about.  Yet, as with Paul the Apostle, I am immensely thankful for the life of Dallas Willard.  For one thing, Willard mentored John Ortberg. . .and I love Ortberg’s writings.  Like Peter the Apostle, Ortberg communicates the deep teachings of Christianity in a way that the majority of us can understand.  In many ways, Romans and 1 Peter communicate similar theological messages.  In like fashion, Willard and Ortberg communicate similar messages regarding the spiritual life.  The Life You’ve Always Wanted (Ortberg) is the layman’s version of Spirit of the Disciplines (Willard); When the Games Is Over, All the Pieces Go Back in the Box (Ortberg) is the layman’s version of Revolution of Character (Willard); Soul Keeping (Ortberg) is the layman’s version of Renovation of the Heart (Willard).  In reading Soul Keeping, I was able to listen in on conversations between pupil and teacher and also to see the mantle of spiritual director move from Willard to Ortberg.

However, if this is all that Soul Keeping is about, then I cannot honestly recommend it to anyone except those who are practicing spiritual directors.  Thankfully, as is common with Ortberg’s works, there is always much more going on beneath the surface.  The volume does serve as a form of extended eulogy for Willard.  It is evident that Ortberg’s extensive ministry that has impacted the lives of so many (including myself and my students who have read Ortberg’s books in their classes) was shaped by the ministry of Dallas Willard.  Willard demonstrated how to care for one’s soul.  Through a lengthy relationship, Ortberg picked up on these lessons and implemented them into his own life, and now communicates those messages in his own books, sermons and workshops. 

In this volume, Ortberg tackles the topic of the soul and how to care for it.  His volume is divided into three major sections.  In the first section, he asks and answers the question of what defines a soul.  According to Ortberg, the “soul is what integrates your will (your intentions), your mind (your thoughts and feelings, your value and conscience), and your body (your face, body language, and actions) into a single life” (p. 43).  A healthy soul, Ortberg argues, is connected with God and functions with integrity.  The challenge, then, is how to develop a healthy soul that functions with integrity.  This is the focus of the second section.  In this section, Ortberg outlines nine “needs” of the soul (e.g., a keeper, a future, rest, freedom and gratitude).  This section is the heart of Ortberg’s book.  Delivered in his classic narrative style, Ortberg clearly defines each “need” and then succinctly delivers avenues that the reader can take to develop a healthy soul.  For example, in the chapter entitled “The Soul Needs Rest,” Ortberg outlines a “cycle of grace” that flows from Jesus’ teaching in Matthew 11:28-30 about his yoke of discipleship (p. 126-127).  The cycle flows from acceptance to sustenance to significance to achievement.  Each movement is centered within grace, which allows us to let go of the need to prove ourselves so that we can find spiritual rest in Christ.  At the end of the chapter, he talks about “doing nothing” and simply enjoying God’s presence.  Throughout the volume, I kept coming to the same conclusion: simple yet profound.

In my humble opinion, the mantle of spiritual director has passed from Dallas Willard to John Ortberg.  Willard will continue to influence us through his books, as he has now gone to receive his eternal reward.  Ortberg continues the legacy of thoughtful, practical spiritual direction through writing in Soul Keeping.  It is likely his best work on spiritual formation, and that is saying something.  However, this does not mean that the volume is perfect.  There are portions of the book where simple prose falls into syrupy simplicity.  However Ortberg does not stay there too long.  Additionally, his views regarding the original sin come out in the chapter on freedom (specifically on p. 151).  While this is certainly not the place to debate the various points of the determinist doctrine, I do believe that it is important to highlight this for potential readers.  Fortunately, Ortberg does not dwell on this, although it central to his belief structure on sin.  Despite these concerns, however, I heartily enjoyed reading Soul Keeping and drinking deeply again from Ortberg’s (and, conversely, Willard’s) well of spiritual wisdom, and gladly recommend it. 

Rob O’Lynn, MDiv
Assistant Professor of Preaching and Ministry
Kentucky Christian University

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the Publisher and was asked to review it.  I was not required to write a positive review.  The opinions I have expressed are my own.  I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Book Review: After Lament (ACU Press Book Club)

Glenn Pemberton.  After Lament: Psalms for Learning to Trust Again.  Abilene, TX: ACU Press, 2014.  220 pp.  $17.99

Thirty years ago, OT scholar Walter Brueggemann, in his book The Message of the Psalms[1], developed the labels of “orientation” (a time of praise), “disorientation” (a time of suffering) and “new orientation” (a time of restoration) as an approach to studying Psalms.  Since its publication, Brueggemann’s cycle of orientation has become the standard paradigm for interpreting and preaching the psalms.  Pemberton has already followed in Brueggemann’s footsteps by focusing on psalms of “disorientation” in his previous volume Hurting with God.[2]  Now, in this new volume, Pemberton indicates that he will be moving on to psalms of “new orientation” to demonstrate how lament moves us toward mature faith in God through the image of a wagon wheel.  With lament at the center, each chapter focuses on a different “spoke”—a different type of psalm—that comes out of lament and brings about that “new orientation” (e.g., psalms of trust, thanksgiving psalms and wisdom psalms).  The volume concludes with a look at some of Pemberton’s “case studies” that he has examined in both volumes.

In terms of evaluation, Pemberton’s volume has both strengths and limitations.  In terms of strengths, this volume speaks with the same pastoral voice as his previous volume Hurting with God.  Pemberton has experienced an immense amount of suffering in a short time, and he shares his suffering in such a way that we find a kindred spirit in these pages rather than a disconnected scholar who has never experienced a moment of anguish.  Additionally, this volume effectively compliments Hurting with God in that Pemberton spends most of this volume focusing on the psalms of “new orientation.”  Although he continues to look at the lament psalms in an effort to bring these texts back into the church’s language and to make us comfortable with them, he does focus a great deal on the prayers and hymns of bygone saints who have emerged from their suffering more confident in their faith.  He is quick, though, to note that “happily ever after” is not a guarantee of “new orientation.”  The sickness or sin is still present; however our hope in God has matured.  Lastly, the general strength of this volume—as with Hurting with God—is the practical approach that the volume takes.  Pemberton has not written for the scholar but for the student, everyday church member and preacher.  His exegesis, if not slightly tinged by his new normal of daily suffering, is solid and communicated with the care and creativity of a veteran preacher. 

However, this does not mean that this volume is free of critique.  There are a couple of minor technical issues that I must address: 1) The boldfacing of selected Psalms is not consistent throughout the volume, and 2) not all of the referenced material makes the Works Cited or Recommended Bibliography sections.  These are minor points of critique, yet I think their mention is warranted.  Now, on a larger scale, there are three major points of critique that I have with this volume.  First, while I appreciate the personal nature with which he writes, I fear that Pemberton borders on using his writing as a form of self-medication.  As someone who has endured a different type of suffering, I can resonate with Pemberton.  There needs to be a place for people of faith to address our concerns to our God.  Yet, drowning in our own sorrows only perpetuates our sorrows.  Second, although the title indicates that he is going to move beyond the psalms of “disorientation,” Pemberton continues to focus predominately on such psalms.  The bulk of this volume rests in that unsettled upward curve between crisis and stability rather than fully moving to “new orientation.”  Third, his “spokes” paradigm is disconnected.  Pemberton envisions the psalms of “disorientation” as the center of a wheel and the psalms of “new orientation” as the spokes that come out of the center.  Taken collectively, he argues, these spokes form a wheel of faith that allows us to continue moving spiritually.  However, the spokes operate more like fan blades.  They are certainly connected to the center, yet they are not connected to one another.  Lament can lead this way or that way, however there is nothing that connects them to one another.  

Still, despite my concerns, this is a solid study and a needed pastoral voice in our religiously shallow world.  If you are not hurting, someone close to you is.  These texts can be your words of solace to them.  If you are hurting, Pemberton gets you.  He understands your pain and wants to help you discover the words you need to offer to God.  This book, along with Hurting with God, would make for a great Bible study (discussion questions are included).  I would also recommend both volumes to the undergraduate instructor who is teaching a text course in Psalms.  That being said, I hope that Pemberton writes a third volume, an “orientation” volume, that will complete the cycle.   

Rob O’Lynn, MDiv
Assistant Professor of Preaching and Ministry
Kentucky Christian University

Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from ACU Press/Leafwood Publishers as part of their ACU Press Bookclub Program.  I was not required to write a positive review.  The opinions I have expressed are my own.  I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”


[1]Walter Brueggemann, The Message of the Psalms: A Theological Commentary (Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1984).
[2]Glenn Pemberton, Hurting with God: Learning to Lament with the Psalms (Abilene, TX: ACU Press, 2013). 

Friday, January 17, 2014

2014 Reading List (I Think)

As promised on Wednesday, here is what I am looking to read in 2014.  They may inspire you, or you may think I'm nuts for reading them.  My reading plan for the first part of this year is to read 1 novel, 1 theological text, and 1 ministry text each month, since I have additional course texts to read.  Think I might like something you're reading?  Leave me a comment or sent me an email!  Happy reading!

Books I am Reviewing

  • Carl Prude, Anchored in Light (ACU Book Club blog)
Books I am Reading for Classes I Teach

  • David Hansen, The Art of Pastoring, rev. ed. (Introduction to Ministry)
  • Timothy Keller, Walking with God through Pain and Suffering (Providence and Suffering)
  • Thomas Long, What Shall We Say? (Providence and Suffering)
  • More will be added, I am sure, when my Fall schedule rolls around
Books I am Reading for My LAST Doctoral Class

  • Dave Bland and David Fleer, ed., Performing the Psalms
  • David Fleer and Dave Bland, ed., Preaching the Eighth-Century Prophets
  • Glenn Pemberton, Hurting with God
  • Fleming Rutledge, And God Spoke to Abraham

Books I am Reading for Fun (Fiction/Philosophy)

  • Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
  • Max Brooks, World War Z
  • Lewis Sinclair, Elmer Gantry
  • Cormac McCarthy, The Road
  • Arthur Miller, Death of a Saleman
  • Jose Ortega y Gassett, Revolt of the Masses
  • George Orwell, Animal Farm
  • Ayn Rand, We the Living or Atlas Shrugged
  • Philip Roth, The Plot Against America
  • Charlie Starr, Light
  • Thornton Wilder, The Bridge of San Luis Rey
  • Jack Wolf, The Tale of Raw Head and Bloody Bones
Books I am Reading for Fun (Homiletics)

  • Kenton Anderson, Choosing to Preach
  • Charles Bartow, God's Human Speech
  • Charles Campbell, The Word Before the Powers
  • Lucy Hogan and Robert Stephen Reid, Connecting with the Congregation
Books I am Reading for Fun (Ministry)

  • Timothy Keller, Center Church (for some consulting work)
  • Melick and Melick, Teaching that Transforms (for my dissertation; yes, this is it!)
Books I am Reading for Fun (Theology)

  • Timothy Keller, Counterfeit Gods
  • Timothy Keller, Every Good Encounter
  • Timothy Keller, Generous Justice
  • Timothy Keller, Jesus the King (aka, King's Cross)
  • Eric Metaxas, Bonhoeffer
  • Philip Yancey, Prayer
  • Philip Yancey, What's So Amazing about Grace?

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

2013 Reading List

Note: I realize it is a tad late, given today is January 15.  However, I have traditionally shared my reading list from the previous year, and I realize that a few of you have asked about it.  So, with that in mind, here is what nourished me spiritually and academically in 2013.  On Friday, I will post my preliminary reading list for 2014.

Books I Reviewed

  • David T. Bourgeois, Ministry in the Digital Age (for Stone-Campbell Journal)
  • Carpenter, Sweet and Blythe, Introduction to Applied Creative Thinking (for Teaching Theology and Religion)
  • Keith Francis and William Gibson, ed., The Oxford Handbook of the British Sermon, 1689-1901 (for Stone-Campbell Journal)
  • Gregory Hunt, Leading Congregations through Crisis (for Stone-Campbell Journal)
  • Rita Schulte, Shattered (for ACU Press "Book Club" blog)
Books I Read for Classes I Teach

  • David Fleer and Dave Bland, ed., Preaching Mark's Unsettling Messiah (Expository Preaching)
  • George Hunter, The Celtic Way of Evangelism (Evangelism in the Local Church)
  • Charles Talbert, Reading Luke, rev. ed. (Gospel of Luke)
  • N. T. Wright, The Early Christian Letters for Everyone (General Letters)
  • Philip Yancey, What Good Is God? (Providence and Suffering)
Books I Read for My Dissertation

  • Karl Barth, Homiletics
  • Joan Bolker, Writing Your Dissertation in Fifteen Minutes a Day
  • Raymond Collins, 1 & 2 Timothy and Titus
  • Edward Farley, Practicing Gospel
  • Luke Timothy Johnson, Letters to Paul's Delegates
  • Kostenberger and Wilder, ed., Entrusted with the Gospel
  • Abraham Malherbe, Paul and the Popular Philosophers
  • Andrew Purves, Pastoral Theology in the Classical Tradition
  • Andrew Purves, The Crucifixion of Ministry
  • Andrew Purves, The Resurrection of Ministry
  • Ronald Sisk, The Competent Pastor
  • Paul Scott Wilson, Preaching and Homiletic Theory
  • Frances Young, The Theology of the Pastoral Letters
Books I Read for Fun

  • Natalie Babbitt, Tuck Everlasting
  • Bonnie Baeder, Who Was Martin Luther King, Jr.?
  • Augsten Burroughs, This Is How
  • Paulo Coelho, The Alchemist
  • Ian Fleming, For Your Eyes Only
  • Ian Fleming, From Russia with Love
  • Ian Fleming, Goldfinger
  • Ian Fleming, Man with the Golden Gun
  • Ian Fleming, Octopussy and The Living Daylights
  • Ian Fleming, On Her Majesty's Secret Service
  • Ian Fleming, The Spy Who Loved Me
  • Ian Fleming, You Only Live Twice
  • Barbara Kingsolver, The Poisonwood Bible
  • C. S. Lewis, The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader
  • Alan Paton, Cry, the Beloved Country
  • Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
  • J. R. R. Tolkien, The Hobbit
  • Leo Tolstoy, The Death of Ivan Ilyich
Books I Read for Seminars

  • C. Leonard Allen, Things Unseen (Theology in Ministry)
  • O. Wesley Allen, Determining the Form (Sermon Development and Delivery)
  • Chris Altrock, Preaching to Pluralists (Connecting Preaching with the Congregation)
  • Bartholomew and Goheen, The Drama of Scripture (Connecting Preaching with the Congregation)
  • Kennon Callahan, Small, Strong Congregations (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • Ron Crandall, Turnaround and Beyond (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • Ruth Ann Gaede, ed., Transitions in Congregations (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • Hicks, Melton and Valentine, A People Gathered (Theology and Ministry)
  • Richard Jensen, Envisioning the Word (Connecting Preaching with the Congregation)
  • Michael Lindvall, The Good News from North Haven (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • Andrew Purves, Reconstructing Pastoral Theology (Theology in Ministry)
  • David Ray, The Indispensable Guide for Smaller Churches (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • Lyle Schaller, Middle-Sized Church (Ministry in Small and Middle-Sized Churches)
  • James Thompson, Pastoral Ministry according to Paul (Theology in Ministry)
  • Jason Vickers, Minding the Good Ground (Theology in Ministry)
  • Sondra Willobee, The Write Stuff (Connecting Preaching with the Congregation)